Evidence that they both drew on the same oral story of Paul
Commentary
can be found at the Vridar
Blog
Prepared from Dennis MacDonald's The Legend and the Apostle (1983) – Neil Godfrey (2007)
The Acts of Paul (numbers reference the online text) |
The Pastorals (See 2 Timothy online) |
2.1-2, 4-5, 17 |
1:15-18 |
Paul travels with Demas and Hermogenes |
Paul's companions had been Phygelus and Hermogenes (the coppersmith) |
To Iconium |
In Asia |
Where he is welcomed by Onesiphorus and his family who remained faithful to Paul |
Where Onesiphorus welcomed Paul and helped him |
Even though he was imprisoned |
Even though he was imprisoned |
2.1, 11-12 |
4:10a |
Demas and Hermogenes desert Paul for a bribe |
Demas deserted Paul for love of this world |
2.14 |
2:17-18 |
Demas and Hermogenes undermine the faith of Thamyris telling him the resurrection is a past event |
Hymenaeus and Philetus undermine others by teaching that the resurrection is a past event |
2.1, 3, 26 |
3:10-11 |
Paul and Thecla leave Iconium, travel on to Lystra and arrive at Antioch where he suffers persecution. (Nothing in common about the circumstances of these persecutions with those in our canonical Acts.) |
Paul suffered persecutions at Antioch, Iconium, Lystra. (The pastoral epistle contradicts the canonical Acts by saying Timothy observed them, but in canonical Acts Timothy did not join Paul till after these persecutions.) |
2.30-35 |
4:14-15 (c.f. 1 Tim 1:19-20) |
Alexander (the coppersmith) opposes Paul and tries to kill Thecla. |
Alexander opposes Paul and appears to threaten his mission in Asia, so Timothy is warned to watch out for him in Ephesus |
Paul in Ephesus (Hennecke Vol.2) |
4:16-19 |
Paul stays with Priscilla and Aquilla . . . |
Paul's friends include Priscilla and Aquilla . . . |
. . . in Ephesus |
. . . in Ephesus |
When “all the house in Ammia turned against Paul” that he might die |
c.f. 1:15 |
Alone, Paul boldly witnessed before the governor and the crowd |
Paul gives his defence alone before a crowd of gentiles |
The governor ordered him eaten by a lion, but the lion refused to eat him and both escaped unharmed |
Paul is saved from a lion |
10.1 |
4:10-11a |
At Rome Luke from Gaul and Titus from Dalmatia were waiting for Paul |
Luke and Titus accompany Paul in Rome; Titus is associated with Dalmatia; and if we read with some texts “Gaul” in place of “Galatia” then one of Paul's companions is a missionary from Gaul. |